Guide

FAT vs SAT: What Is the Difference?

A factory acceptance test (FAT) happens in the panel shop before shipping and proves the panel and program match the design, using simulated signals. A site acceptance test (SAT) happens after installation and proves the whole system works with the real field devices and process. FAT finds build and program problems early; SAT finds what only shows up on site.

Timeline

Where Each Test Happens

FAT and SAT sit at either end of shipping and installation. Each one checks a different kind of risk.

  • FAT: in the shop, before shipping
  • Installation and field wiring in between
  • SAT: on site, with the real process
  • Both are recorded and signed
Testing timeline: build inspection, electrical tests and functional tests in the WETS AI shop, the factory acceptance test which customers can witness, shipping and installation, then the site acceptance test with real field devices.
Compare

FAT and SAT Side by Side

Both tests use a written procedure. The difference is what is connected to the panel when it runs.

FATSAT
WherePanel shopYour site, after installation
WhenBefore shippingAfter installation and field wiring
SignalsSimulated I/OReal instruments and equipment
What it provesPanel and program match the designThe system works with the process
Typical problems foundWiring errors, program logic, screen issuesField wiring, instrument ranges, process tuning
Cost to fixLow: tools and parts are at handHigher: travel, downtime and access
Getting Ready

What to Have Ready Before SAT

Most SAT delays come from things that are not ready on site. Check these before the test date.

Site

  • Panel installed, anchored and grounded
  • Field wiring complete and checked
  • Power available at the right voltage

Process

  • Instruments installed and calibrated
  • Equipment ready to run safely
  • Water, product or air available to test with

People

  • Operators and maintenance available
  • Signed FAT records and punch list on hand
  • SAT procedure agreed in advance
Water treatment filters at a customer site during commissioning, with test equipment on site
Site acceptance testing at a treatment plant
Why Both

Why Skipping FAT Costs More on Site

Every problem fixed at FAT is one less problem during startup, when the plant is waiting and every hour costs money. In the shop, the drawings, parts and tools are on hand, and nothing is running.

SAT is still needed, because some things can only be proven on site: the field wiring, the real instruments, and how the process actually behaves. With a good FAT behind it, SAT can focus on those.

FAQ

Common Questions

Is SAT the same as commissioning?

They overlap. Commissioning is the wider process of bringing the system into service. SAT is the formal test, with a written procedure, that proves it works and is accepted.

Can FAT be done remotely?

Parts of it can, by video, but a witnessed FAT in person lets you see and operate the panel yourself. At WETS AI, witnessed FAT is available on request.

Who writes the FAT and SAT procedures?

Usually the system integrator or panel shop, based on the control narrative, with the customer reviewing and approving them.

Does WETS AI support SAT?

Yes. We verify the system on site with your team, using the real field devices and process.

Related

Related Guides & Services

FAT Checklist

What to check, and what to ask for, at a factory acceptance test.

Request a Quote

Ready for a Quote?

Send what you have: drawings, an I/O list or a short description of the process. We will reply with questions, a quotation and a schedule.

Call Request a Quote